Comparing the Athena and Melody Water Ionizers at All Levels
Filed Under: Water Ionizer Comparisons
Filed Under: Water Ionizer Comparisons
In the following videos and chart I am comparing the Athena and Melody water ionizers. These water ionizers are both Jupiter water ionizers.
Jupiter is a well-known brand name for medical-grade water ionizers that you can trust for their quality and dependability.
The Jupiter Athena water ionizer is the high-end Jupiter model which has DARC cleaning [best internal self-cleaning of all of the water ionizers], mesh plates and dual filtration, and sells for $2095.00 verses the Melody water ionizer [the moderately priced Jupiter water ionizer, which cleans itself great, is electro-plated [solid plates which are platinum-coated with peaks and groves for greater surface area for better electrolysis], and sells for $1395.00]. The Melody often comes very close in water ionizer comparison tests, so I think it’s a great choice for anyone on a budget. The Lifetime Warranty makes either of these water ionizers an even sweeter deal!
Athena vs Melody Water Ionizer Comparisons
|
Water Ionizer / Level |
pH |
ORP |
rH |
Acid |
|
Athena L3 |
11.54 |
-650 |
8.08 |
|
|
Melody L3 |
11.52 |
-550 |
11.37 |
|
|
Athena L4 |
11.77 |
-680 |
7.54 |
4.08 |
|
Melody L4 |
11.75 |
-605 |
10 |
3.65 |
|
Athena L2 |
11.41 |
-746 |
4.62 |
|
|
Melody L2 |
11.52 |
-578 |
10.44 |
|
|
Athena L1 |
10.93 |
-472 |
12.79 |
|
|
Melody L1 |
11.16 |
-482 |
12.92 |
|
|
Athena Purified |
10.64 |
-93 |
26.84 |
|
|
Melody Purified |
10.57 |
-145 |
23.77 |
|
|
STL Tap Water |
10.5 |
+200 |
34.33 |
|
Here’s my analysis: It looks like the Athena beats the Melody in every level for rH [water drinking healthiness per level of pH], but the Melody is testing very good. They are both producing very healthy water! I don’t think you could go wrong with purchacing either of these water ionizers.
The healthiness of the water is measured a few ways. I’ll explain:
The aging body tends to become more and more acidic as life goes on [especially if we eat junk food or have an acidic diet over a period of years]. For this reason, we need water which is alkaline, so we can replenish our buffers to ward against the tendancy toward acidity. Otherwise our cells have no way of getting rid of their toxins. So pH is a factor in the healthiness of water.
- Water ionizers produce a high alkaline pH. Even the water ionizer I purchased 17 years ago produced a nice high pH. Of course you don’t need the extremely high pH [that some water ionizers produce] for drinking purposes. Drinking water at a moderately high pH can help alkalize your body and get rid of the acidic wastes that have built up in your cells.
- Oxidation is also a factor in the health of one’s body. Like a cut apple that turns brown, our cells tend to become over oxidized. I don’t know if the cells turn brown or not, but damage of one kind or another [commonly referred to as free-radical damage] happens when the cells are oxidized. To combat the body’s tendancy toward free-radical damage, theoretically, one would consume antioxidants. A way to test the antioxidant quality of a liquid is to measure its ORP [Oxidation Reduction Potential]. The more negative the ORP, the better. Any ORP with a greater negativity than -300 is considered “medical grade” ORP.
-
- My personal experience with drinking water that has a high negative ORP [between -300 and -600] is that things like wrinkles and spider veins reduce when you drink water that has a higher negative ORP. I’m sure that the ORP is good for other things as well; basically anything that you would take antioxidants for would benefit from the consumption of water with a high negative ORP.
- The rH [relative Hydrogen] of a solution is based on a formula applied to the pH and ORP to arrive at the relation between the level of ORP to the level of pH. It is the best measure of the healthiness of that ionized water. I always consider the rH to be the most important measure to look at in any water ionizer comparison test.
- Here’s an example: if you have two water ionizers producing water at a pH of 9.5, and one has an ORP of -300 and the other has an ORP of -400, then the one with -400 is producing water at a healthier overall quality. Most people testing water ionizers don’t get the exact same pH readings for all the water ionizers tested. So the rH formula is necessary to really see which water ionizer is producing the healthier water. The formula is a very simple one, and anyone comparing water ionizers should look at the rH of the water at the drinking water levels if they are trying to figure out which water ionizer is best. Because ORP is a very tricky measure to get and ORP meters can vary from test to test [depending on how well or frequently they're cleaned, source water and other factors] it’s important to only compare the ORP or rH of water ionizers tested in one setting by the same tester. RH is measured on a scale of 0 to 42, with 0 being the healthiest and 42 the unhealthiest. Tap water in St. Louis is usually around 30 – 35 rH. Any water under 28 rH is considered “reducing” and so is healthy for you.
- “The relative hydrogen scale was first proposed by Clark in 1923 to the scientific community (mostly inorganic chemists) as a means of measuring the true reducing power of hydrogen present in an aqueous solution…”* Go to this website to see this article and get a more thorough and scientific explanation of rH: http://h-minus-ion.vpinf.com/rH-score-1.html
Wishing You Water Wellness!
Sincerely,
Cathleen LoGrasso
Blog-Master












Hi, I found this site very interesting. Didn’t review all of it, but will be interested in buying a unit. I think you feel the Athena is the best overall product. My daughter bought a Enagic for a ton of money, and it sounds like the Athena is at least comparable but less ex-pensive. Is there a business opportunity selling these? Please advise. Many thanks.
Helena
PS – Your site is very interesting!!
Hi Helena!
I have 4 water ionizers in my house and the one I use for best drinking water is the Athena [it has better filtration and gets the best ORP per unit of pH]. The one I use to get the lowest acid water is the Tyent Turbo. I don’t have the Enagic in my house, but my friend has one. When given the choice which water to drink …I choose the Athena over the Enagic. The Athena gives more ORP per unit of pH than the Enagic in every test I’ve done personally and every test I’ve seen others do on the internet. If I had a choice of any water ionizer for the lowest acid water I’d choose either the Enagic or the Tyent Turbo. You can buy the Athena without becoming a member of IonWays [an MLM company]. However if you’re looking for a business opportunity, the IonWays company is much more personable, friendly, professional, non cutthroat, honest, and inexpensive. I think all these things will in the end add up to better profitability.